The Science of Good and Evil by Michael Shermer

Last updated: Oct 4, 2023

Summary of The Science of Good and Evil by Michael Shermer

1. The Dual Nature of Human Morality

In "The Science of Good and Evil," Michael Shermer explores the dual nature of human morality, arguing that it is a product of both biological and cultural factors. He explains that our moral instincts are rooted in our evolutionary history, as they have been shaped by natural selection to promote cooperation and social cohesion. However, Shermer also emphasizes the role of culture in shaping our moral beliefs and values, as societies develop their own moral codes and norms.

This insight is actionable because it helps us understand that our moral intuitions are not fixed or absolute. Instead, they are influenced by both our biology and the society we live in. By recognizing this, we can engage in critical thinking and reflection to evaluate our moral beliefs and consider alternative perspectives. This can lead to a more nuanced and empathetic understanding of morality, allowing us to make more informed and ethical decisions in our daily lives.

2. The Evolutionary Origins of Altruism

Shermer delves into the evolutionary origins of altruism, challenging the notion that it is solely driven by selflessness. He argues that altruistic behaviors can be explained by the concept of reciprocal altruism, where individuals help others with the expectation of receiving help in return. This perspective suggests that altruism can be advantageous from an evolutionary standpoint, as it promotes cooperation and mutual benefit.

This insight is profound because it challenges the traditional view of altruism as purely selfless and highlights the evolutionary benefits of cooperation. It encourages us to recognize that acts of kindness and generosity can have reciprocal benefits, fostering a sense of interconnectedness and mutual support. By understanding the evolutionary origins of altruism, we can cultivate a greater appreciation for the power of cooperation and empathy in building a more compassionate and harmonious society.

3. The Influence of Moral Foundations

Shermer explores the concept of moral foundations, which are the underlying principles that shape our moral beliefs and judgments. He identifies six key moral foundations: care/harm, fairness/cheating, loyalty/betrayal, authority/subversion, sanctity/degradation, and liberty/oppression. These foundations provide a framework for understanding the diverse range of moral values and perspectives found across different cultures and individuals.

This insight is original to general knowledge because it highlights the multidimensional nature of morality and the various factors that contribute to our moral judgments. By recognizing the influence of moral foundations, we can better understand and appreciate the diversity of moral beliefs and values. This can foster greater tolerance and empathy towards others, as we recognize that different individuals and cultures may prioritize different moral foundations.

4. The Role of Reason in Moral Decision-Making

Shermer explores the interplay between reason and emotion in moral decision-making. He argues that while emotions often drive our initial moral intuitions, reason plays a crucial role in evaluating and justifying these intuitions. He emphasizes the importance of critical thinking and rational analysis in moral deliberation, as it allows us to consider the consequences and ethical implications of our actions.

This insight is actionable because it encourages us to engage in reflective and reasoned moral decision-making. By recognizing the role of reason in shaping our moral beliefs, we can strive to make more informed and ethical choices. This involves questioning our initial intuitions, considering alternative perspectives, and evaluating the evidence and logical arguments surrounding moral issues. By incorporating reason into our moral decision-making process, we can enhance our ethical judgment and contribute to a more just and compassionate society.

5. The Illusion of Objective Morality

Shermer challenges the notion of objective morality, arguing that moral values and judgments are subjective and culturally constructed. He highlights the diversity of moral beliefs across different societies and individuals, suggesting that there is no universal moral standard that applies to all situations and contexts.

This insight is profound because it challenges the idea that there is an absolute and objective moral truth. It encourages us to recognize the subjective nature of morality and the importance of cultural context in shaping our moral beliefs. This understanding can foster greater humility and open-mindedness, as we recognize that different individuals and cultures may have valid and legitimate moral perspectives. By embracing the subjective nature of morality, we can engage in more constructive and empathetic moral discourse, promoting mutual understanding and respect.

6. The Power of Moral Progress

Shermer explores the concept of moral progress, highlighting how societies have evolved and improved their moral values over time. He argues that moral progress is driven by a combination of cultural, social, and technological advancements, as well as increased empathy and moral reasoning.

This insight is original to general knowledge because it emphasizes the potential for positive change and moral improvement. By recognizing the power of moral progress, we can be inspired to actively contribute to the betterment of society. This involves advocating for social justice, promoting equality, and challenging unjust practices and beliefs. By striving for moral progress, we can create a more compassionate and equitable world for future generations.

7. The Dark Side of Morality

Shermer explores the dark side of morality, highlighting how moral beliefs and values can be manipulated and exploited for nefarious purposes. He discusses the role of moralistic aggression, where individuals or groups use moral justifications to justify acts of violence and oppression.

This insight is actionable because it alerts us to the potential dangers of moral absolutism and the manipulation of moral beliefs. By being aware of the dark side of morality, we can critically evaluate moral arguments and be cautious of individuals or groups who use moral justifications to promote harmful ideologies. This understanding can help us resist the influence of extremist ideologies and contribute to a more tolerant and inclusive society.

8. The Importance of Moral Education

Shermer emphasizes the importance of moral education in fostering ethical behavior and moral reasoning. He argues that moral education should go beyond teaching a specific set of moral values and instead focus on developing critical thinking skills, empathy, and a sense of moral responsibility.

This insight is actionable because it highlights the role of education in shaping moral character and behavior. By prioritizing moral education, we can equip individuals with the necessary tools to navigate complex moral dilemmas and make ethical choices. This involves promoting empathy, encouraging open-mindedness, and fostering a sense of moral responsibility towards others. By investing in moral education, we can contribute to the development of a more compassionate and ethical society.

Related summaries

• The Moral Landscape by Sam Harris
• The Righteous Mind by Jonathan Haidt
• The Better Angels Of Our Nature by Steven Pinker
• The Evolution of Cooperation by Robert Axelrod
• The Origins of Virtue by Matt Ridley
• The Lucifer Effect by Philip Zimbardo
• The Moral Animal by Robert Wright
• The Happiness Hypothesis by Jonathan Haidt
• The Blank Slate by Steven Pinker
• The Selfish Gene by Richard Dawkins
• The Social Animal by David Brooks
• The Empathy Exams by Leslie Jamison
• The Moral Arc by Michael Shermer